钱江源-百山祖国家公园候选区钱江源园区科学研究到治理实践的转化特征

Characteristics of the science-governance implementation translation in the Qianjiangyuan National Park Candidate Area

  • 摘要: 科学研究向治理实践的有效转化是提升国家公园治理成效的关键。钱江源-百山祖国家公园候选区钱江源园区作为中国东部人口密集地区和经济发达地区国家公园建设的先行者, 在国家公园体制试点期间及后续创建期间均积累了丰富的科研成果与治理实践经验。研究以钱江源园区为例, 从转化阶段、转化层级和时间, 以及转化驱动主体等角度出发, 对钱江源园区的“科研-实践”转化特征进行分析。研究发现:(1)“科研-实践”转化阶段呈现两种模式。生态保护主题与社区协调主题的生态补偿领域具有完整的“探索性-适应性”阶段, 而可持续生计、自然教育和游憩、文化宣传领域尚处于科研实践探索性阶段。(2)“科研-实践”转化层级上存在跨级实施特征, 体现为政策原则层建议转化为落地行动层实践, 技术标准层的科研建议转化率最低。(3)转化时间统计结果显示, 从科研建议提出到治理实践落地的平均时间为1.2a。技术标准类建议转化所需时间最长, 落地行动类建议转化所需时间最短。部分治理行动存在先于科学研究的现象, 主要集中在文化服务主题。(4)转化驱动主体方面, 决策主体参与科研会提高“科研-实践”转化效果, 减少转化的时间滞后性。研究从科学家与管理者全流程合作、补充社会经济监测课题、拓宽科研建议的获取渠道等角度提出建议。

     

    Abstract: It is crucial to bridge the "knowing-doing gap" between scientific research and governance implementation, and achieve their effective translation for enhancing the governance effectiveness of national parks. While existing studies often focus on static thematic matching analyses, this paper introduces a "theme+level" dual-dimension classification system and constructs a full-process "exploratory-adaptive" stage model for the translation from scientific research to governance implementation. With the Qianjiangyuan National Park Candidate Area, located in a densely populated region of eastern China, as a case study, a quantitative analysis of 184 academic papers and 88 governance practice items was conducted. The translation characteristics were systematically evaluated from four dimensions: translation stage, translation level, time lag, and driving subject.The results indicate that: (1) Translation Stage: Two typical models emerge. For the theme of ecological conservation and the area of ecological compensation within community coordination, a complete "exploratory-adaptive" cycle was formed, with existing reflective research actively promoting the implementation of adaptive governance. In contrast, areas such as sustainable livelihood, nature education, and cultural promotion remain in the "exploratory" stage, lacking effective mechanisms for evaluating governance outcomes and providing feedback. This discrepancy primarily stems from managers′ varying demands for evaluation feedback and the higher implementation difficulty of relevant evaluative research for scientists. (2) Translation Level: The process exhibits "cross-level implementation" characteristics. Scientific recommendations at the "policy principle" level often translate directly into governance practices at the "action" level. Nevertheless, recommendations at the "technical standard" level exhibit the lowest translation rate. Recommendations with high certainty translate more readily than adaptive ones. This reflects a deep-seated tension between the current operational logics of scientific research and governance implementation, with commissioned projects serving as a key intermediary "technology translator". (3) Time Lag: Statistics show an average lag of 1.2 years from the proposal of scientific recommendations to the implementation of governance practices. Recommendations related to technical standards take the longest to translate, while action-oriented recommendations translate most rapidly. Notably, some governance actions preceded the relevant scientific research, a phenomenon concentrated in the theme of cultural services. (4) Driving Subject: The involvement of decision-makers in scientific research enhances translation effectiveness and effectively shortens the time lag. This is attributed to the demand orientation of decision-makers, which increases the responsiveness to practical problems, as well as the long-term stable collaborative networks, which further strengthen the credibility of the science. Finally, this paper suggests that national parks should promote full-process collaboration between scientists and managers, prioritize supplementing socio-economic monitoring to improve feedback mechanisms for social coordination and cultural service themes, broaden channels for accessing scientific recommendations, and build collaborative networks for joint research and governance.

     

/

返回文章
返回